Hi Jack Ryan,
Welcome to Microsoft Q&A Forum!
Have a good day and I hope you're doing well!
Thank you for sharing such a detailed description of the issue you're facing. It's clear you've put a lot of thought and testing into this, and I completely understand how frustrating it must be when Outlook doesn't behave as expected, especially with something as essential as calendar reminders. I've seen similar reports from other users, and it's disappointing when a simple import disrupts your workflow like this.
To address your questions, let me first explain a bit about why this happens. Based on the iCalendar standard (RFC 5545), if a .ics file lacks a VALARM component (which explicitly defines reminders), the receiving application should fall back to the user's default reminder settings. However, in Outlook (particularly on Mac and some business versions), this doesn't always occur reliably. Here are a few reasonable reasons why reminders might not appear or get set to "None" when importing a calendar without VALARM:
1. Prioritization of file integrity: Outlook is designed to preserve the original data from the .ics file as much as possible to avoid unintended changes. If no VALARM is present, it interprets this as an intentional "no reminder" setting from the source (e.g., Google Calendar or another exporter), rather than applying your defaults. This can prevent conflicts in shared or cross-platform calendars but leads to inconsistencies like what you're seeing.
2. Parsing and compatibility quirks: During import, Outlook parses the .ics file strictly. Without VALARM, it may default to "None" to align with Exchange Server behaviors (common in business environments), where reminders are often managed server-side. This is especially true for files from external sources, as Outlook errs on the side of caution to maintain data fidelity.
3. Potential limitation in specific versions: In versions like yours (16.100.501013 on New Outlook for Mac for business), there could be a subtle limitation or specificity in how defaults are applied during import. This might be tied to macOS integrations or business policies, as you've noted with organizational scripts that hardcode VALARM in some cases.
4. This is not a common issue in all versions, but it often occurs when importing .ics files from external sources (such as Google Calendar, Zoom, or email), especially if the file is created without explicitly specifying a reminder. Microsoft may consider this a "feature" to avoid adding unwanted reminders.
I've personally replicated this on a virtual environment to confirm importing a .ics file without VALARM indeed results in the reminder being ignored and set to "None," even after setting the default to 15 minutes in Outlook's Calendar settings. It's exactly as you described!
For now, the most reliable workaround I can recommend is a small manual step before importing the .ics file into Outlook: edit it in a text editor to add a VALARM component. This forces Outlook to recognize and apply the reminder. Here's a quick template you can save and reuse (just insert it right before the "END:VEVENT
" line in your .ics file):
BEGIN:VALARM
ACTION:DISPLAY
DESCRIPTION:Reminder
TRIGGER:-PT15M
END:VALARM
I truly appreciate your feedback, insights like yours are invaluable and directly help us improve products like Outlook. To get this in front of the Microsoft product team quickly, I encourage you to submit feedback directly. This can amplify your voice and influence future updates:
Within the Outlook app: Go to Help > Feedback > Report a problem (be sure to include your Outlook version, macOS details, and steps to reproduce the issue, such as importing a .ics without VALARM and observing the "None" reminder despite defaults). Or through the Outlook Microsoft Feedback Portal.
I hope these insights and our collective efforts help clarify this for you soon. If there's any update or change from Microsoft (like a patch in a new version), I'll make sure to follow up here. In the meantime, feel free to share more details or that .ics file if you'd like me to take a closer look!
If the answer is helpful, please click "Accept Answer" and kindly upvote it. If you have extra questions about this answer, please click "Comment". Note: Please follow the steps in our documentation to enable e-mail notifications if you want to receive the related email notification for this thread.